Nirmala Sitharaman Criticized for Evasive Tax Comment
Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman faced a wave of criticism on social media following her cryptic response to a question about the high taxes imposed on stock market brokers and real estate transactions. The incident took place at an event at the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), where a stockbroker voiced concerns over the heavy tax burden on stock market activities and property purchases. The broker pointed out that while investors take on significant risks, the government, referred to as a “sleeping partner,” gains substantial revenue through various taxes including GST, IGST, Stamp Duty, Securities Transaction Tax (STT), and Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) Tax.
The broker also raised issues related to the real estate sector, highlighting the extensive taxes involved in buying a house, such as Stamp Duties and GST. He emphasized the challenges faced by individuals with limited resources in affording a home and the difficulties brokers encounter due to the plethora of taxes, arguing that the government, as a passive partner, benefits disproportionately from the profits.
In response, Nirmala Sitharaman, smiling, replied, “A sleeping partner cannot answer sitting here.” This comment quickly sparked strong criticism on Reddit, where users expressed their disappointment with what they perceived as the minister’s dismissive attitude towards a serious concern. Many netizens had expected a more substantial and considerate response from Sitharaman, given the significant impact of high taxes on investors and homebuyers.
The social media backlash reflected broader frustrations with the financial burdens on those involved in the stock market and real estate sectors. Critics argued that such heavy taxation stifles investment and creates barriers to homeownership, particularly for those with limited financial means.
During the same event, Sitharaman also called on the BSE to work closely with the Securities & Exchange Board of India (SEBI) to enhance investor confidence through stringent compliance and robust regulatory standards. This appeal underscored the need for maintaining high standards in capital markets to protect investors and ensure market integrity.
Overall, the incident underscored growing concerns among investors and homebuyers about current tax policies and their impact on financial activities and economic participation. Sitharaman’s response, seen by many as insufficient, highlighted these issues, prompting calls for more comprehensive and empathetic solutions from the government.
Follow for more.